Should You Grade?Should You Grade?
Card ExplorerSetsTop CardsPop ScannerMarket ToolsBlogUpgrade
Sign In
Charmander #58

Charmander #58

Pokemon Fire Red & Leaf Green · #58 · Base · Aug 2004

Buy Raw on eBayPSA 10 Sold on eBay
Shop on TCGPlayer

Maybe — Proceed with Caution

Should You Grade?

Raw Price
$2.00
Expected Value
$23.20
Net Profit
$31.50
Gem Rate
5.3%
ROI
+185%
Sales / Yr
142

The gem rate is only 5% — you'll need a very clean copy to hit PSA 10.

ⓘPopulation data match confidence: 61% — verify on PSA

Best Tier for Flipping

TAG Basic$22.00/card · 30+ business days
Net Profit $42.50
Per-Flip ROI 127%
Annualized 2,340%
Unlock with Pro →

Factors in grading cost, turnaround time, and compounding — how fast you can reinvest profits into the next flip.

Profitability by Grading Company

CompanyBest TierGem RatePop10sCostEVNet ProfitROI
PSAPSA Standard52.3%8,4201,250$20.00$85.40$32.50127%
BGSBGS Standard52.3%8,4201,250$20.00$85.40$32.50127%
CGCCGC Standard52.3%8,4201,250$20.00$85.40$32.50127%
SGCSGC Standard52.3%8,4201,250$20.00$85.40$32.50127%
TAGTAG Standard52.3%8,4201,250$20.00$85.40$32.50127%
Compare All Companies with Pro →

Shows the best-value tier from each grading company based on EV, cost, and turnaround. Pop = total graded population; 10s = grade 10 count.

Price by Grade

Raw
$2.00
BGS 10
$156.00
PSA 10
$120.31
SGC 10
$72.00
9
$59.00
8
$53.21
CGC 10
$48.50
BGS 9.5
$28.00
7
$14.99
View Sold PSA 10 Prices on PriceCharting →View Grading Data on GemRate →
0%100%
5.3%Gem Rate (PSA 10)

Grade Distribution (359 total graded)

359Total
PSA 10195.3%
PSA 912334.3%
PSA 810228.4%
PSA 74612.8%
Below 76818.9%
© 2026 Should You Grade? Data from PriceCharting & GemRate.
AboutContactPrivacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAffiliate Disclosure